In the wake of the Competition Commission of India’s (CCI) investigations into alleged media cartelization, pressure is mounting on media agency leaders in the Advertising Agencies Association of India (AAAI).
The raids on March 18 sent shockwaves through the advertising world, as CCI officials stormed the offices of major agencies — including GroupM, Dentsu, Omnicom, Havas, Madison, IPG and Publicis. Key industry bodies, including AAAI, the Indian Society of Advertisers (ISA), and IBDF, were also under the scanner, with operations spanning Delhi, Mumbai, and Gurugram. The allegations against the media agencies center on anti-competitive practices and media cartelization, raising concerns about transparency and ethical governance within the industry.
AAAI’s leadership includes executives from the agencies under investigation. Critics argue that their continued presence could compromise the integrity of AAAI, a body meant to uphold industry standards.
A seasoned advertising industry veteran minced no words: “How can we expect a fair investigation when top media agency executives under CCI scrutiny continue to lead AAAI? They must step down immediately to allow a neutral leadership to take over.” The demand for resignations is not just about optics but about ensuring a level playing field in the industry, the executive said, on the condition of anonymity.
Industry voices echo similar concerns, emphasizing that the move should have come voluntarily. “This is about transparency and fairness. These leaders should have stepped aside on their own. That would have sent a strong message about industry ethics and cooperation,” said another senior insider.
Advertisers are also weighing in, insisting that agency executives from agencies under investigation should not govern AAAI until they receive a clean chit from CCI. “They can remain members but should not hold leadership roles. Stepping down would rebuild trust,” a leading advertiser stated.
Adding to the turbulence, smaller agencies are preparing to submit a formal representation demanding an overhaul of the AAAI board, as per multiple industry sources. Some are even pushing for a separate industry body to protect their interests. The disenchantment of smaller agencies with AAAI is not new; however, the ongoing controversy has given fresh momentum to their calls for reform.
“Independent agencies struggle to get a foothold in AAAI – it’s like an elite club controlled by a powerful few,” said the founder of an independent agency. “The high membership fees and restrictive entry barriers make it almost impossible for smaller players to join. It’s time for change.”
With the industry at a crossroads, all eyes are on AAAI.
Read more: EXCLUSIVE: CCI examines emails of former IBDF President K Madhavan, key officials